By Jeremy Jacobs - 07/12/09 12:28 PM EDT
“I am really flabbergasted by the depth and consistency of her philosophical critique of the ideal of impartial justice,” Sessions said on CBS’s “Face the Nation.”
Sessions said he’s uncomfortable that Sotomayor has “advocated a view that suggests that your personal experiences, even prejudices,” will influence decisions.
That, he added, “is a blow at the very ideal of American justice.”
He also said such views can determine a justice’s opinions more often on the Supeme Court than on lower courts.
Sessions’s comments come one day before Sotomayor's confirmation hearings open on Monday. Sotomayor, Obama’s first pick for the high court, appears set to sail through to confirmation given the Democratic 60-seat majority in the Senate.
Sen. Charles SchumerCharles SchumerDems' Florida Senate primary nears its bitter end Trump was wrong: Kaine is a liberal in a moderate's clothing Trump poised to betray primary supporters on immigration MORE (D-N.Y.) on Sunday predicted Sotomayor would win as many or more than the 78 votes won by Chief Justice John Roberts in his confirmation hearing.
Senate Judiciary Chairman Patrick LeahyPatrick LeahyProtecting generic pharma competition is necessary now The U.S. and Nigeria’s Buhari on the human rights hot seat 'CREATES Act' would only create more lawsuits MORE (D-Vt.), appearing with Sessions, said his colleague was “grasping at straws” in trying to criticize Sotomayor.
“Here's a woman who was a mainstream judge and who deserves respect as a judge,” Leahy said.
Leahy said he has discussed the concerns raised by Sessions with Sotomayor, who would be the first Latina Supreme Court justice. Sotomayor, Leahy went on, said that “ultimately and completely” the law controls her opinions, and not any personal bias.
“Anything else is nitpicking and gives the impressions that a lot of people were going to oppose anybody, anybody that President Obama came up with,” Leahy said.